The short answer
Take the Albufeira trip if you are staying in or near Albufeira and want dolphin watching in the same outing. Plan on about two and a half hours from Marina de Albufeira and a cave visit that is short by rule, not by choice of the operator.
What is on the tour
Listings describe a coastal cruise past cliffs and beaches, the Benagil cave when conditions allow, and in the combined tours a dolphin-watching segment of 45 minutes to an hour. Operators say sightings cannot be guaranteed, so treat the dolphins as a possible extra, not part of the price you pay for the cave. Check what the listing says if you see none.
Why the distance figures differ
One operator gives 18 km from the marina to the Alfanzina Lighthouse, which is not the whole way to Benagil, and another gives 25 km by sea from Albufeira to the cave. They are not contradictory, because they measure different legs. We do not publish a single distance; use the duration.
Rules and alternatives
The beach inside the cave is closed to landing and boat visits are capped (Wikipedia), so the time at the cave is a few minutes; see the cave rules. If Albufeira’s longer trip does not suit you, Lagos and Portimão are the other main starts, and all of them are compared in Benagil tours by town.
Frequently asked questions
How long is the Benagil cave tour from Albufeira?
Most operator listings say about 2.5 hours and return to Marina de Albufeira. Some list about 2 hours.
Do Albufeira tours include dolphin watching?
Many combine the cave with a dolphin-watching part, listed as 45 minutes to one hour. Sightings are not guaranteed, according to the listings.
How far is Benagil from Albufeira by boat?
Listings disagree: one operator describes 18 km to the Alfanzina Lighthouse and another 25 km by sea to the cave, so they measure different things. Duration is the more useful figure.
How long do boats stay in the cave?
Wikipedia reports that, since August 2024, each boat's visit is capped at two minutes and vessels are limited in number. One guide says kayaks get about eight minutes.
Some links are affiliate links: if you book through them we earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. It funds the research behind this site.